All insights

Asda’s problem is in the aisles, David Potts knows it but can he fix it?

Andrew Busby · 7 November 2026 · 4 min read

Asda’s problem is in the aisles, David Potts knows it but can he fix it?

Boardroom strategy is usually the glamorous part of a supermarket turnaround. David Potts has opened his tenure by dismissing it. In his first address to staff at Leeds headquarters, he said Asda will “win or lose” based on its ability to turn around its patchwork store standards. For a chief executive in his first week, that is an unusually plain thing to say.

However, he knew it needed saying, he had been visiting stores “incognito” in the weeks before his appointment, so his diagnosis comes from a shopper’s view of the shelves, not from a consultant’s slide. Although quite what Allan Leighton might have said upon hearing this assessment of his two years in charge, one wonders.

Andrew's Retail Reflections is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Why the diagnosis is right

Asda’s recent history is a case study in what happens when a retailer takes its eye off the basics. The trade press has linked the slide to brutal cost-cutting after a disastrous $1bn IT overhaul, including multiple rounds of redundancies. Fewer people in stores means emptier shelves, tired fresh counters and queues. Shoppers notice, and they leave.

Price cuts cannot fix that. As one analyst put it, there is only so much further price cuts can achieve if shoppers aren’t consistently getting the experience they expect. A cheap shop is no bargain when the thing you came for isn’t on the shelf.

The leaks are also getting bigger. Asda’s share sat at 12.6% in early 2025, down from 13.6% a year earlier, and by spring Aldi had overtaken it on food and drink sales. Meanwhile 2026 began with free-falling market share and falling sales. A major upgrade to the fresh and frozen aisles in May has yet to bring the consistency experts want.

Why Potts is the right man

He started on the shop floor at 16, and rose through Tesco to run its Irish, UK and Asian businesses before taking over Morrisons. At Morrisons he led a turnaround that restored its fresh food heritage. A former Asda buyer calls him someone who understands the nuts and bolts of stores, which is a different skill from marketing. Allan Leighton has a gift for the big gesture, and the two men complement each other. Potts’s promise of “week by week” improvement is modest, but a shopper can check it on every visit, so it is a promise he can be held to.

The headwinds

But the aisles today are a very different place.

First, the market has moved on. The grocery sector Potts returns to looks very different from the one in which he turned things around at Morrisons. Aldi and Lidl are still opening stores, and the price perception gap with them has not closed. Asda must fix its stores while fending off rivals with simpler, cheaper models.

Second, there is the ownership structure. Asda has been under the Issa brothers and TDR Capital since the £6.8bn takeover, and there is doubt over whether even Potts can overcome the drag of that ownership situation. A heavily leveraged business has little spare cash for the staffing and refits that standards depend on. Ambition on shop-floor quality sits uneasily with a balance sheet that rewards cost-cutting. Much of his work is going to need to be focused on persuading the owners that investment in the store estate is urgently needed.

Third, it’s not just about fixing the store standards, the grocery sector is finally embracing innovation, the goalposts are constantly shifting meaning today’s grocery benchmark is a digital store, customers expect more. To make a dent in market share won’t merely take better service, better standards and, crucially, better availability, but a more digital experience for its customers.

The verdict

Can Potts make Asda’s stores consistently good? He is the most credible person available for the job, and the fixes are known: more staff on the floor, better availability, fresh food done properly. But that’s not the full picture, the estate is tired when compared with the competition and that’s no quick fix.

Can he restore Asda to the growth and share it once enjoyed? That is much less certain. Good stores are necessary, but they will not by themselves win back shoppers who have found Aldi. And they cannot be funded without the owners accepting lower short-term returns.

So Potts is right that Asda will win or lose on its stores, but the stores are only the first test. If he fixes them, he will have earned the right to a harder fight over price, funding and ownership. Asda’s customers are waiting for the first of those results, the jury is out on whether it will come.

Andrew's Retail Reflections is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Start the conversation

Ready to build momentum?

Contact Andrew